State Select Water Heater Reviews: The Brutal Truth Before You Buy
The sudden, shocking blast of icy water mid-shower is a universal homeowner nightmare. It’s often the first sign that your trusty water heater, a silent workhorse hidden away in a closet or basement, is failing. When this happens, the urgent, often stressful, search for a replacement begins, and one name you will undoubtedly encounter is State Select.
But with so many brands and models, how do you know if a State Select water heater is the right choice for your home? You’re likely worried about reliability, longevity, and overall value. This guide cuts through the noise to provide a comprehensive, no-nonsense review of State Select water heaters, helping you make a confident and informed decision.
You'll Learn About
Who Really Makes State Select Water Heaters?
First, it’s crucial to understand the brand’s pedigree. State Water Heaters is a brand owned by A.O. Smith, one of the largest and most well-known water heater manufacturers in the world. This connection is significant because it means State products benefit from the extensive engineering, manufacturing experience, and technology of a major industry leader.
The “Select” line typically refers to their standard, widely available series of gas and electric tank-style water heaters. These are the models most frequently installed by professional plumbers, known for their durable, no-frills construction. For homeowners seeking a deeper dive into the parent company’s offerings, exploring an AO Smith Water Heater Guide can provide valuable context on shared technologies and quality standards.
Unpacking the State Select Models: Gas vs. Electric
State Select water heaters primarily come in two flavors: natural gas and electric. Each has distinct advantages and is suited for different homes and priorities. Understanding these differences is the first step in narrowing down your choice.
State Select Gas Water Heaters
Gas models are often favored for their lower operating costs and faster recovery rates. This means they can heat a full tank of water more quickly than their electric counterparts, a key benefit for larger families with high hot water demands. Key features often include a self-cleaning dip tube to reduce sediment buildup and advanced electronic gas controls for precise temperature management and diagnostics.
However, gas heaters typically have a higher upfront purchase price and require professional installation with proper venting for safety. Improper venting of a gas appliance can be extremely dangerous, so this is not a DIY project for the inexperienced.
State Select Electric Water Heaters
Electric water heaters are generally less expensive to purchase and simpler to install, as they don’t require gas lines or complex venting. This makes them a versatile option for many homes. They operate using one or two heating elements to warm the water inside the insulated tank.
The primary drawback is that electric models can have higher monthly operating costs, depending on local electricity rates. They also have a slower recovery rate, which might be a concern for households that use a lot of hot water in short periods. Many homeowners also look for ways to optimize their energy usage, even with tank-style units. While often associated with on-demand systems, some wonder, can you put a timer on a tankless water heater? The principles of scheduled heating can sometimes be applied to tank models as well to manage energy consumption.
Core Features to Scrutinize Before Buying
Beyond the fuel type, several key specifications determine a water heater’s performance, lifespan, and suitability for your home. Paying close attention to these details will ensure you get a unit that meets your needs without overpaying for unnecessary capacity or features.
Tank Capacity and Sizing
Choosing the right size is critical. A tank that’s too small will leave you with cold showers, while an oversized one wastes energy. For gas heaters, look at the First Hour Rating (FHR), which tells you how many gallons of hot water the unit can produce in its first hour of operation. For electric heaters, the tank’s gallon capacity is the primary sizing metric. A 40-50 gallon tank is typically sufficient for a household of 2-4 people.
Energy Efficiency (UEF Rating)
Modern water heaters are rated using the Uniform Energy Factor (UEF). This metric measures a water heater’s overall energy efficiency. A higher UEF means lower energy consumption and reduced utility bills over the life of the appliance. While a high-UEF model might cost more upfront, the long-term savings can be substantial.
Warranty and Long-Term Durability
State Select models typically come with a 6-year limited warranty on the tank and parts, which is standard for the industry. However, the true key to a water heater’s longevity lies in its internal components, particularly the anode rod. This sacrificial rod is designed to corrode away, protecting the steel tank from rust. Many homeowners are unaware that this part needs to be inspected every few years and replaced when depleted, a simple step that can double the life of the tank.
Real User Reviews: The Good, The Bad, and The Ugly
Searching online forums and review sites reveals a consistent picture of State Select water heaters. Many users report impressive longevity, with units lasting 10, 15, or even 20 years with minimal issues. They are often described as reliable “workhorses” that do their job without fuss.
However, negative reviews tend to focus on the failure of specific components, such as the gas control valve or thermocouple, sometimes just a few years into service. Some users have also reported issues with premature tank leaks. It’s important to note that proper installation and regular maintenance are the two biggest factors influencing any water heater’s lifespan and reliability, regardless of the brand.
State Select Model Comparison
To help you visualize the options, here is a simplified breakdown of the main State Select lines and their intended applications.
| Model Type | Capacity Range | Key Feature | Best For |
|---|---|---|---|
| Standard Gas (Atmospheric Vent) | 30-50 Gallons | Self-Cleaning Dip Tube | Homes with existing vertical venting and moderate hot water needs. |
| Standard Electric | 30-80 Gallons | Dual Heating Elements | All-electric homes or installations where gas venting isn’t feasible. |
| Power Vent Gas | 40-75 Gallons | Blower-Assisted Venting | Basements or locations without a direct vertical chimney. |
| High-Efficiency Gas | 50 Gallons | Higher UEF Rating | Homeowners prioritizing long-term energy savings. |
Pro Tips for Maximizing Your Water Heater’s Lifespan
A new water heater is a significant investment. Protecting that investment requires proactive maintenance that goes beyond the “set it and forget it” mentality. These simple steps can add years to the life of your State Select unit.
Annual Flushing is Non-Negotiable
Sediment, rust, and mineral scale are the number one enemies of a tank-style water heater. This buildup forces the unit to work harder, reduces efficiency, and can lead to premature tank failure. Draining a few gallons of water from the drain valve at the bottom of the tank once a year helps flush out this harmful sediment.
Inspect and Replace the Anode Rod
As mentioned earlier, the anode rod is your tank’s primary defense against corrosion. It’s a simple, inexpensive part that is designed to be consumed. An inspection every 3-5 years can tell you if it needs replacement. Replacing a spent anode rod can be the difference between a 7-year and a 15-year lifespan for your tank.
Consider Your Water Quality
The quality of the water entering your appliances has a direct impact on their longevity. Hard water, rich in minerals like calcium and magnesium, accelerates sediment buildup and can wreak havoc on heating elements and valves. Protecting your investment in a new water heater also means considering the quality of your water supply. This is why some homeowners investigate solutions like whole-house filtration or wonder about the Linx drinking water system cost as part of a broader home maintenance strategy.
The Final Verdict: Is a State Select Water Heater a Smart Buy?
After a thorough review of its features, user feedback, and brand reputation, the conclusion is clear. A State Select water heater is a solid, dependable, and value-oriented choice for most homeowners. It may not offer the cutting-edge smart features or the highest possible efficiency ratings of some premium brands, but it delivers on the core promise of reliable hot water.
Its strength lies in its simplicity, durable construction, and the backing of a major manufacturer like A.O. Smith. When installed correctly by a qualified professional and maintained properly, a State Select unit can provide many years of trouble-free service, making it a worthy contender for your home.
