Shiplap Subfloor: Is Your Old Floor a Hidden Problem?
You’ve pulled back the old carpet or vinyl in your historic home, only to discover a layer of wide wooden planks running underneath. This isn’t the smooth plywood you’re used to seeing; it’s a shiplap subfloor, a relic of a bygone construction era. Now, you’re faced with a critical question: is this charming piece of history a solid foundation for your new flooring, or a disaster waiting to happen?
Many homeowners find themselves in this exact situation, excited by the character of their old house but worried about the structural integrity of a shiplap subfloor. Can you install modern flooring like tile or hardwood directly over it? Will it be noisy, uneven, or worse, lead to costly damage down the line? This article will guide you through the history, problems, and solutions associated with shiplap subfloors, helping you make the best decision for your home renovation project.
You'll Learn About
What Exactly Is a Shiplap Subfloor? A Look Back
Before the widespread use of plywood and OSB (Oriented Strand Board) after World WarII, solid wood planks were the standard for subflooring. These planks, often made from pine, were typically 1×6 or 1×8 boards. They were installed directly over the floor joists to provide a structural base for the finished floor.
True shiplap boards have a special “rabbet” joint, a groove cut into the edge of the board that allows it to overlap with the adjacent board. This overlapping design created a stronger, more stable surface and helped to minimize drafts from below. In many older homes, these subfloor planks were laid diagonally to the joists, which added significant stiffening and strength to the entire floor system.
The Shift to Modern Subflooring
The post-war building boom saw a shift towards more cost-effective and uniform materials like plywood. Plywood panels are made from thin layers of wood veneer glued together in alternating directions, giving them strength and stability in all directions. This made them a more predictable and often more reliable subfloor material compared to the natural wood planks of a shiplap subfloor, which could warp, shrink, or have inconsistencies.
This history is important because it highlights a key difference: shiplap subfloors were part of a different building system with different expectations. While they were perfectly adequate for the types of flooring used at the time (like solid hardwood nailed directly to the planks), they can present challenges for modern flooring materials that require a perfectly flat and stable surface.
Common Problems with Shiplap Subfloors
Discovering a shiplap subfloor can be exciting, but it often comes with a set of potential problems that need to be addressed before you can even think about installing new flooring. Ignoring these issues can lead to squeaky floors, uneven surfaces, and even failure of your new flooring material.
Uneven Surfaces and Gaps
Over decades, the solid wood planks of a shiplap subfloor can dry out and shrink, creating gaps between the boards. These gaps can range from small cracks to significant spaces, leading to a few problems. Firstly, they can create drafts, allowing cold air from the basement or crawlspace to enter the living area. This might have implications for your home’s energy efficiency; you can learn more about how factors like sunlight affect room temperature in our passive heating guide.
Secondly, the planks themselves can cup or warp over time, resulting in an uneven surface. Modern flooring materials, especially rigid ones like tile and some types of laminate, require a very flat subfloor for proper installation. An uneven shiplap subfloor can cause these materials to crack, separate, or fail prematurely.
Squeaks and Bounce
One of the most common complaints about homes with shiplap subfloors is squeaky floors. Squeaks are often caused by the wood planks rubbing against each other or against the nails that hold them to the joists. As the wood expands and contracts with changes in humidity, the fasteners can loosen over time, allowing for movement and noise.
A bouncy or spongy feeling underfoot is another red flag. This can be a sign of insufficient support from the floor joists or that the shiplap planks themselves are not thick or strong enough for the span between the joists. While shiplap was once a common building material, its use has evolved. You might be interested to learn about other historical building materials in our article that explores the history of car decking.
Moisture and Rot
Like any wood product, shiplap subfloors are susceptible to moisture damage. Leaks from plumbing, spills, or high humidity in a basement or crawlspace can lead to rot and decay. This can compromise the structural integrity of the subfloor, creating soft spots and making it unsafe. Issues with moisture can sometimes be complex, similar to how a tankless water heater’s temperature can fluctuate due to various factors.
Before proceeding with any new flooring installation, it’s crucial to thoroughly inspect the shiplap subfloor for any signs of water damage, past or present. This includes looking for discoloration, staining, or areas that feel soft or spongy when you apply pressure.
To Keep or Replace? Assessing Your Shiplap Subfloor
Once you’ve identified the potential problems with your shiplap subfloor, the next step is to decide whether to keep it and work with it, or to remove it and start fresh with a modern subfloor material. This decision will depend on the condition of the shiplap, your budget, and the type of flooring you plan to install.
When You Might Keep Your Shiplap Subfloor
If your shiplap subfloor is in good condition—meaning it’s relatively flat, has minimal gaps, and shows no signs of rot or significant damage—you may be able to keep it. This is often the most cost-effective option, and it preserves a piece of your home’s history. However, you will almost certainly need to add a layer of underlayment on top of the shiplap to create a suitable surface for your new flooring.
Even if you keep the shiplap, it’s a good idea to secure any loose planks by screwing them down to the joists. This will help to minimize squeaks and create a more stable base. Be sure to use screws that are long enough to go through the shiplap and well into the joists.
When Replacement Is the Better Option
In some cases, the shiplap subfloor may be too damaged or uneven to be salvaged. If you find extensive rot, large gaps, or significant cupping and warping, it’s often best to remove the old planks and install a new subfloor of plywood or OSB. While this is a more involved and expensive process, it will give you a solid, flat, and reliable foundation for your new flooring.
Replacing the subfloor also gives you the opportunity to inspect and, if necessary, repair the floor joists. You can also add insulation between the joists to improve your home’s energy efficiency. If you’re planning to install a heavy flooring material like ceramic or stone tile, starting with a new, sturdy subfloor is highly recommended.
Preparing a Shiplap Subfloor for New Flooring
If you’ve decided to keep your shiplap subfloor, proper preparation is key to a successful new flooring installation. This usually involves cleaning, repairing, and adding a layer of underlayment to create a smooth and stable surface.
Step 1: Cleaning and Repairs
Start by thoroughly cleaning the shiplap subfloor. Remove any old nails, staples, or adhesive residue. Vacuum up any dust and debris. Next, inspect the entire subfloor for loose planks and screw them down to the joists to eliminate squeaks and movement.
If there are any damaged or rotted planks, they should be replaced. You can often find reclaimed lumber that will match the dimensions of your existing shiplap. Small gaps can be filled with a wood filler, but for larger gaps, you may need to install a layer of plywood underlayment.
Step 2: Choosing and Installing Underlayment
For most modern flooring materials, you’ll need to install a layer of underlayment over the shiplap subfloor. The type and thickness of the underlayment will depend on the flooring you’re installing. Plywood is a common choice for underlayment over shiplap. A thickness of at least 1/2 inch is generally recommended to provide a smooth, stable surface and to bridge any minor imperfections in the shiplap.
When installing the plywood underlayment, be sure to stagger the seams so that they don’t line up with the seams in the shiplap below. Use screws to attach the plywood to the shiplap and the joists, ensuring a secure and stable installation. For some flooring types, like tile, you may need to install a cement backer board over the plywood underlayment.
| Subfloor Material | Pros | Cons | Best For |
|---|---|---|---|
| Shiplap (Original) | Historical character, potentially cost-effective if in good condition. | Prone to gaps, unevenness, squeaks, and moisture damage. Not suitable for direct installation of many modern floors. | Solid hardwood flooring (with proper preparation). |
| Plywood Underlayment | Creates a smooth and stable surface, bridges gaps in shiplap, good for a variety of flooring types. | Adds height to the floor, requires additional cost and labor. | Laminate, vinyl, engineered wood, and as a base for tile backer board. |
| OSB (Oriented Strand Board) | Generally less expensive than plywood, structurally stable. | Can swell and degrade when exposed to moisture. | Carpet, laminate, and some types of vinyl flooring. |
| Cement Backer Board | Provides a stable and water-resistant surface for tile. | Heavy and can be difficult to cut and install. Must be installed over a stable subfloor like plywood. | Ceramic, porcelain, and natural stone tile. |
Installation Tips for Common Flooring Types Over Shiplap
The type of flooring you choose will have a big impact on how you prepare your shiplap subfloor. Here are some specific tips for common flooring materials:
Hardwood Flooring
Solid hardwood flooring can sometimes be installed directly over a shiplap subfloor, as this was a common practice in older homes. However, the shiplap must be in excellent condition—flat, solid, and with no significant gaps. It’s generally recommended to install a layer of felt paper or a similar underlayment between the shiplap and the new hardwood to act as a moisture barrier and to reduce squeaks.
When installing hardwood over shiplap, it’s best to run the new flooring perpendicular to the shiplap planks. If the shiplap is installed diagonally, you have more flexibility in the direction of your new hardwood. For engineered hardwood, it’s almost always better to install a plywood underlayment first.
Laminate and Vinyl Plank Flooring
Laminate and vinyl plank flooring are “floating” floors, meaning they are not nailed or glued to the subfloor. This makes them a good option for installing over a shiplap subfloor, but you’ll still need a smooth and flat surface. A layer of 1/4-inch or 1/2-inch plywood underlayment is highly recommended to ensure a successful installation.
Many laminate and vinyl plank products come with a pre-attached underlayment, but you may still need a separate vapor barrier, especially if you’re installing over a crawlspace or basement. Always follow the manufacturer’s instructions for the specific product you’re using.
Ceramic and Porcelain Tile
Installing tile over a shiplap subfloor requires the most preparation. Tile is a rigid material that is very unforgiving of any movement or unevenness in the subfloor. Attempting to install tile directly over shiplap is a recipe for cracked tiles and grout.
To properly install tile over a shiplap subfloor, you will need to first install a layer of at least 1/2-inch plywood underlayment. On top of the plywood, you will then need to install a layer of cement backer board. This will provide the stable, water-resistant surface that tile requires. This multi-layer approach will add significant height to your floor, so be sure to plan for transitions to adjacent rooms.
Conclusion: A Solid Foundation for Your Home’s Future
A shiplap subfloor is a unique feature of many older homes, but it can present challenges when it comes to installing new flooring. By carefully assessing the condition of your shiplap, addressing any problems, and properly preparing the surface, you can create a solid and stable foundation for the flooring of your choice. Whether you decide to keep and repair your historic subfloor or replace it with a modern material, taking the time to do the job right will ensure that your new floors are beautiful, durable, and will last for years to come.
Don’t let the discovery of a shiplap subfloor derail your renovation plans. With the right knowledge and preparation, you can turn this potential problem into a success story, preserving the character of your home while updating it for modern living. Taking these steps will not only give you a beautiful new floor but also the peace of mind that comes with knowing it’s built on a solid foundation.
