Grizzle Gray vs Peppercorn: The Dark Gray Paint Mistake You Can’t Afford to Make
Choosing a dark gray paint seems simple until you’re standing in front of two nearly identical swatches. This is the classic dilemma between Sherwin Williams Grizzle Gray (SW 7068) and Peppercorn (SW 7674), a choice that can dramatically alter the mood and style of your space.
Making the wrong selection can lead to a room feeling colder, smaller, or clashing with your existing decor. The subtle differences between these two popular charcoal grays are significant, and understanding them is the key to a perfect finish.
You'll Learn About
Grizzle Gray vs. Peppercorn: The Core Differences
At first glance, Grizzle Gray and Peppercorn are very similar deep, moody grays. They sit right next to each other on the Sherwin Williams color strip, which often adds to the confusion. However, their undertones and light reflectance values set them apart.
Grizzle Gray (SW 7068) is the lighter of the two and possesses noticeable green or sometimes slightly blue undertones. Peppercorn (SW 7674), on the other hand, is a darker, more neutral charcoal that is often considered a soft black with subtle, cool undertones that can flash purple or blue in certain light.
Unmasking the Undertones: The #1 Deciding Factor
The biggest mistake homeowners make is ignoring the undertones. Grizzle Gray’s green undertone is distinct and will be more pronounced in rooms with a lot of natural light or when paired with crisp whites. This makes it a fantastic choice for exteriors or for creating a grounded, earthy feel indoors.
Peppercorn’s undertones are far more subdued, making it a truer, more versatile charcoal. It provides a dramatic, sophisticated backdrop that works well for modern accent walls, kitchen cabinets, and interior doors. Its neutrality allows it to pair with a wider range of colors without clashing.
LRV: The Brightness Battle You Can’t Ignore
Light Reflectance Value (LRV) measures how much light a paint color reflects. The scale runs from 0 (absolute black) to 100 (pure white). The difference here is small but impactful.
Grizzle Gray has an LRV of 13, meaning it’s a dark color that will absorb a lot of light. Peppercorn is even darker, with an LRV of 10. This three-point difference means Peppercorn will read as a much deeper, almost-black shade on the wall, while Grizzle Gray retains more of its gray character.
| Feature | Sherwin Williams Grizzle Gray (SW 7068) | Sherwin Williams Peppercorn (SW 7674) |
|---|---|---|
| LRV (Light Reflectance Value) | 13 | 10 |
| Primary Undertone | Green, sometimes blue | Neutral, can flash cool blue or purple |
| Color Family | Green | Neutral / Purple |
| Best For | Exteriors, earthy interiors, rooms with warm light | Accent walls, cabinets, modern interiors, exteriors |
| Feels Like | Grounded, moody, complex | Dramatic, sophisticated, soft black |
The Sheen Secret: How Finish Changes Everything
One of the most overlooked aspects when choosing between these two colors is the paint sheen. The finish—whether matte, eggshell, or satin—can completely transform how these dark shades appear in your room. This is a critical detail that paint chips simply cannot convey.
A matte finish on Peppercorn will absorb the maximum amount of light, enhancing its soft black quality and creating a velvety, ultra-sophisticated surface. This is ideal for a home theater or a dramatic accent wall. A matte finish on Grizzle Gray, however, can sometimes make its green undertone appear muddy in low light.
Conversely, a satin or semi-gloss finish will reflect more light. On Grizzle Gray, this can beautifully highlight its complex green undertones, making it a stunning choice for kitchen cabinets or exterior trim. For Peppercorn, a higher sheen can bring out its subtle cool undertones, which you must be prepared for.
Grizzle Gray vs. Peppercorn: A Room-by-Room Showdown
Choosing the right color depends heavily on the application and the unique lighting of your space. What works for an exterior might not work for a north-facing living room.
For Exteriors: The Clear Winner
For home exteriors, Grizzle Gray is often the preferred choice. Its green undertone connects beautifully with natural landscaping, stone, and wood elements. It stands up to bright, direct sunlight without looking washed out, providing a rich, complex charcoal that feels both modern and timeless.
Peppercorn is also a stunning exterior color, offering a crisp, high-contrast look, especially when paired with bright white trim. However, its darker nature means it will absorb more heat, a factor to consider in warmer climates. The choice between them often comes down to matching existing materials like roofing or stonework; understanding their undertones is crucial, as is deciding between different shades of gray grout in stonework.
For Cabinets and Accent Walls
When it comes to kitchen cabinets, islands, and interior accent walls, Peppercorn often takes the lead. Its neutral charcoal base provides a solid, dramatic anchor that feels incredibly high-end. It pairs seamlessly with marble or quartz countertops and brass or black hardware.
Grizzle Gray can also be used for cabinets, but you must be committed to its green undertone. It can create a beautiful, moody-green-gray look that is unique and custom. Pairing it with the right neutral wall color is key, as colors like beige can sometimes clash. Navigating neutral paint comparisons, like the differences between Shiitake and Accessible Beige, is a similar challenge.
For Living Rooms and Bedrooms
In living spaces, the choice is highly dependent on lighting and desired mood. In a well-lit, south-facing room, either color can create a cozy, enveloping feel. Peppercorn will deliver a more dramatic, modern vibe, while Grizzle Gray offers a softer, more organic moodiness.
Be cautious using these colors in small, dark, or north-facing rooms, as they can feel heavy and confining. If you love the color but fear the commitment, consider using it on a single accent wall behind a bed or fireplace. The task of choosing the right gray can be as complex as deciding between popular greige tones, a common issue seen in the Revere Pewter vs Worldly Gray debate.
The Final Verdict: How to Choose With Confidence
There is no single “better” color between Grizzle Gray and Peppercorn. The right choice is the one that harmonizes with your home’s unique features and your personal style.
Choose Sherwin Williams Grizzle Gray if:
- You want a dark gray with a distinct, earthy green undertone.
- You are painting an exterior and want it to connect with landscaping.
- Your space has warm-toned woods or finishes that will complement the green.
Choose Sherwin Williams Peppercorn if:
- You need a versatile, true charcoal that acts as a neutral.
- You want a dramatic, sophisticated “soft black” for cabinets or an accent wall.
- Your space has cool-toned finishes and you want a crisp, modern look.
The ultimate rule is to always test samples. Paint large swatches on your wall and observe them at different times of the day—morning, noon, and night—to see how they react to your home’s changing light. This final step will prevent the costly mistake of choosing a color that looked perfect on the chip but fails on the wall.
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the main differences between Grizzle Gray and Peppercorn?
Grizzle Gray (SW 7068) is a dark charcoal gray with noticeable green or sometimes blue-green undertones. Peppercorn (SW 7674) is a slightly darker, more neutral dark gray that is often described as a soft black. While Peppercorn can sometimes show subtle purple or blue undertones, it is generally considered closer to a true gray than Grizzle Gray.
Which color is darker, Grizzle Gray or Peppercorn?
Peppercorn is the darker of the two colors. It has a Light Reflectance Value (LRV) of 10, meaning it is very close to black. Grizzle Gray has an LRV of 13, making it slightly lighter than Peppercorn but still a very dark and dramatic shade.
What are the undertones of Grizzle Gray?
Grizzle Gray has strong green undertones. In certain lighting conditions, these undertones can also appear somewhat blue-green or teal. These undertones give the color more depth and can make it feel more organic and less cold than a neutral gray.
What are the undertones of Peppercorn?
Peppercorn is considered a more neutral gray, but it can have subtle undertones. Depending on the lighting, it can show hints of inky blue or even purple. Some experts describe it as a “true gray” because its undertones are not as strong as in other charcoal colors.
Which color would be better for my home’s exterior?
Both Grizzle Gray and Peppercorn can be excellent choices for a home exterior, creating a bold and sophisticated look. Because it has more noticeable undertones, Grizzle Gray can appear more complex, shifting between blue, green, and gray in different lights. Peppercorn provides a classic, deep charcoal appearance that creates a strong contrast with lighter trim colors.
