Quiet Moments vs Sea Salt: The #1 Mistake to Avoid
NOT DUPLICATE
Choosing the perfect paint color can feel like an impossible task. You stand in front of a wall of a thousand subtly different swatches, each promising to transform your space into a serene oasis. Two of the most popular contenders in the search for tranquility are Benjamin Moore’s Quiet Moments and Sherwin Williams’ Sea Salt.
On the surface, they appear similar—both are soft, muted, and endlessly calming. But this similarity is deceptive, leading many homeowners to make a critical mistake that results in a room that feels completely wrong. The subtle differences in their undertones can dramatically alter the mood of your home, turning your intended spa-like retreat into a gloomy, cold space.
This guide will dissect the DNA of these two iconic colors. We will reveal their true character, expose their tricky undertones, and provide a definitive framework for choosing the right one for your home, ensuring you create the peaceful atmosphere you’ve been dreaming of.
You'll Learn About
Unveiling Benjamin Moore Quiet Moments (1563)
Quiet Moments is a beloved color for a reason. It’s a sophisticated and airy shade that evokes a sense of calm and clarity, reminiscent of a misty morning. It’s the color you choose when you want to create a space that feels like a deep, relaxing breath.
The Core Essence of Quiet Moments
At its heart, Quiet Moments is a delicate balance of blue, green, and gray. Its Light Reflectance Value (LRV) is 60.73, placing it in the light range. This means it’s an excellent choice for making a room feel brighter and more spacious without being stark or cold.
It has enough saturation to be a distinct color, yet it’s muted enough to function as a neutral backdrop for your decor. Think of it as a chameleon that adapts to its surroundings while maintaining its core serene identity.
The Hidden Undertones: A Blue-Gray Heart
The most crucial factor to understand about Quiet Moments is its dominant undertone: blue. While it has green and gray to soften it, the blue is what you will notice most, especially in certain lighting conditions. This is the “mistake” many people make—they see the green on the swatch and are surprised by how blue it appears on their walls.
In rooms with cooler, northern-facing light, the blue and gray undertones will be more pronounced, creating a crisp, tranquil, and almost formal feel. In warmer, southern-facing light, the subtle green can emerge, softening the color and making it feel more balanced.
Where Quiet Moments Shines Best
This color is a fantastic choice for creating a spa-like atmosphere in bathrooms and bedrooms. Its calming blue undertones promote relaxation and rest. It also works beautifully in living rooms and home offices where a peaceful, focused environment is desired.
Because of its ability to reflect light, it’s a great option for smaller spaces or rooms that don’t receive a ton of natural light. It can bring an airy, expansive quality to an otherwise modest room.
Decoding Sherwin Williams Sea Salt (SW 6204)
Sherwin Williams’ Sea Salt is another fan-favorite, consistently ranking as one of the brand’s best-selling colors. It’s often described as the perfect coastal-inspired shade, capturing the essence of a breezy, sun-drenched day by the ocean.
The Core Essence of Sea Salt
Sea Salt is a quintessential green-gray. Its LRV is 63, which is very similar to Quiet Moments, meaning it also does a great job of reflecting light. It is soft and muted, capable of creating a relaxed and casual atmosphere in any room.
Where Quiet Moments feels like a quiet morning mist, Sea Salt feels like the fresh, salty air of the coastline. It’s an incredibly versatile color that can lean either sophisticated or beachy depending on the decor you pair it with.
The Chameleon Undertones: A Green-Gray Soul
The defining characteristic of Sea Salt is its green undertone. This is what sets it apart from Quiet Moments. While it has a healthy dose of gray to keep it from looking like a true mint green, the green is almost always present. In some lighting, a hint of blue can peek through, but it is fundamentally a green paint color.
This is where lighting becomes critical. In a south-facing room with lots of warm light, Sea Salt will look like a beautiful, soft sage green. In a north-facing room, the gray will become more prominent, and it can sometimes flash a subtle blue, making it feel cooler and more muted.
Where Sea Salt Performs Beautifully
Sea Salt is incredibly versatile. It’s a go-to choice for living rooms, kitchens, bedrooms, and even laundry rooms. Its connection to nature makes it a calming color that doesn’t feel overly cold.
It’s particularly stunning in homes with a coastal, farmhouse, or cottage aesthetic. Paired with crisp white trim and natural wood tones, it creates a timeless and inviting look. The right paint quality, as explored in comparisons like the Showcase vs Emerald showdown, can further enhance its rich character.
The Head-to-Head Showdown: Quiet Moments vs. Sea Salt
Now that we understand the individual personalities of these colors, let’s put them side-by-side. The decision between them almost always comes down to one critical factor: your preference for blue versus green undertones.
Choosing incorrectly based on the paint chip is the biggest mistake you can make. You must see how their undertones behave in your home’s unique lighting before making a final decision.
The Ultimate Comparison Table
Here is a direct comparison to help you visualize the key differences and make a more informed choice.
| Feature | Benjamin Moore Quiet Moments | Sherwin Williams Sea Salt |
|---|---|---|
| Primary Identity | A soft, airy blue-gray | A soft, earthy green-gray |
| LRV (Light Reflectance Value) | 60.73 (Slightly less reflective) | 63 (Slightly more reflective) |
| Dominant Undertone | Blue | Green |
| Feels In North-Facing Light | More blue and gray, cooler, crisp | More gray, can flash blue, muted |
| Feels In South-Facing Light | Balanced, green may appear, softer | More green, warmer, sage-like |
| Best For Creating This Mood | Spa-like, serene, tranquil, ethereal | Coastal, airy, natural, relaxed |
| Ideal For These Spaces | Bedrooms, bathrooms, meditation spaces | Living rooms, kitchens, entryways |
LRV: The Brightness Battle
With LRVs of 60.73 and 63, both colors are firmly in the “light” category. Sea Salt is technically a tiny bit brighter, meaning it will reflect slightly more light back into the room. However, this difference is so minimal that it is unlikely to be noticeable to the naked eye.
You should not base your decision on LRV alone. The perceived brightness will be far more influenced by the undertones and how they react to your home’s natural and artificial lighting.
Undertone Deep Dive: The Deciding Factor
This is the most important part of your decision. Do you want a room that leans blue or a room that leans green? If you love the idea of a calming, spa-like retreat with a clear blue sky or water influence, Quiet Moments is your color.
If you are drawn to more earthy, nature-inspired colors and want a versatile shade that feels fresh and grounded, Sea Salt is the winner. Its green-gray composition connects beautifully with natural elements like wood furniture and indoor plants.
The Unspoken Factor: How Sheen Transforms These Colors
A critical detail often overlooked is the paint’s sheen. The finish you choose—matte, eggshell, satin—can significantly impact how these colors appear on your walls, especially their complex undertones.
A matte finish has no shine and will absorb light, which can make colors like Quiet Moments and Sea Salt appear softer and more muted. This can be great for hiding minor wall imperfections but may slightly dull the color’s vibrancy. A satin or semi-gloss finish, on the other hand, reflects light. This will make the undertones—the blue in Quiet Moments and the green in Sea Salt—more pronounced and noticeable. For most walls, an eggshell finish offers the best of both worlds: a soft, low-sheen look with good durability.
Choosing Your Champion: A Practical Decision Guide
Feeling overwhelmed? Let’s simplify it. Follow this step-by-step guide to make the right choice with confidence.
Step 1: Understand Your Lighting
Before you even buy a sample, analyze your room’s light. Does it face north (cool, indirect light), south (warm, bright light), east (warm morning light), or west (warm evening light)? As we’ve discussed, cool light will amplify the blue/gray tones, while warm light will bring out the green.
Step 2: The “Must-Do” Sampling Test
Never, ever choose a paint color based on a small paper swatch from the store. You must test large samples directly on your walls. Paint a large square (at least 2×2 feet) of both Quiet Moments and Sea Salt on the main wall of the room.
Place the swatches a few feet apart so your eyes don’t blend them. Observe them throughout the day—in the morning, at noon, and at night with your artificial lights on. This is the only way to see how their undertones will truly behave in your specific environment.
Step 3: Consider Your Existing Finishes
Look at your flooring, cabinets, furniture, and countertops. If you have warm wood tones or creamy beige carpets, the green in Sea Salt will likely harmonize better. If you have cool gray tiles, crisp white cabinets, or black accents, the blue in Quiet Moments might be a more sophisticated fit.
Coordinating Colors: Perfect Pairings
Once you’ve made your choice, you need the right trim and accent colors to complete the look. The right combination will elevate the main color from simply “nice” to absolutely stunning. Selecting the right product line, such as understanding the difference between Behr Pro vs Premium Plus, can also impact the final finish and durability.
Best Trim Colors for Quiet Moments
To enhance its crisp, ethereal quality, pair Quiet Moments with a clean, bright white trim. Benjamin Moore’s Chantilly Lace or Sherwin Williams’ Extra White are excellent choices. For a softer, more blended look, a slightly off-white like Benjamin Moore’s White Dove works beautifully.
Best Trim Colors for Sea Salt
Sea Salt looks phenomenal with a crisp white trim, which makes its green-gray tones pop. Consider Sherwin Williams’ Pure White or High Reflective White. For a creamier, more rustic farmhouse feel, an off-white like Sherwin Williams’ Alabaster is a perfect companion.
Final Verdict: The Truth on Which Color Wins
In the battle of Quiet Moments vs. Sea Salt, there is no universal winner. The “best” color is the one that best suits your home’s unique lighting and your personal aesthetic preference. Neither is objectively better, but one will almost certainly be better for your space.
The victory comes not from picking the more popular color, but from understanding their fundamental differences. Quiet Moments is a blue-dominant color that creates a serene, spa-like mood. Sea Salt is a green-dominant color that creates a relaxed, coastal-inspired vibe.
By testing them properly on your walls and observing how their undertones come to life, you avoid the number one mistake: being surprised by the final result. Take the time to follow these steps, and you will be rewarded with a beautiful, tranquil space that feels just right.
