Farrow & Ball Matched to Sherwin Williams: The Brutal Truth
You’ve fallen in love. It wasn’t with a person, but with a paint color. Specifically, a Farrow & Ball color with a beguiling name like ‘Elephant’s Breath’ or ‘Hague Blue.’
You can already picture its rich, complex tones transforming your living room. Then you see the price tag and the limited availability, and a practical problem emerges: How can you get that coveted, high-end look without the logistical or financial headache? This leads countless homeowners and designers to ask the million-dollar question: can Sherwin-Williams perfectly match a Farrow & Ball color?
The short answer is “almost,” but the complete story is far more complex. While modern technology can get you incredibly close, a perfect one-to-one match is often elusive. Understanding why is the key to successfully getting the color you want with the paint you can easily buy.
You'll Learn About
Why Match Farrow & Ball to Sherwin-Williams? The Age-Old Dilemma
The desire to cross-brand paint colors stems from a classic conflict between aspiration and practicality. On one hand, you have the undeniable allure of Farrow & Ball. Their colors are celebrated for their incredible depth and chalky, soft finish, which is a result of high-quality pigments and a unique formulation.
On the other hand, Sherwin-Williams offers undeniable advantages in accessibility, affordability, and variety. With thousands of stores, a broad range of durable paint lines for every conceivable surface, and the trust of professional painters everywhere, it represents a more practical choice for many projects.
The Science of the Near-Miss: Why a Perfect Match Is So Hard
Before you march into a store with a Farrow & Ball paint chip, it’s crucial to understand the scientific hurdles involved in color matching. It isn’t as simple as a machine reading a color and spitting out an identical formula.
The Metamerism Trap: This is the single most important concept to understand. Metamerism is a phenomenon where two colors appear to be a perfect match under one light source (like the fluorescent lights of a paint store) but look distinctly different in another, such as the natural daylight of your home. This happens because the two paints, from different brands, use different pigment formulas to achieve a similar color. Those different pigments reflect light differently, causing the perceived color to shift with the light source.
Base and Sheen Matter Immensely: Every paint brand has its own unique base formulas. Some are inherently warmer or cooler, which subtly influences the final color. More importantly, the sheen you choose (matte, eggshell, satin, etc.) dramatically alters how a color looks. A higher-gloss finish reflects more light, often making a color appear lighter and more saturated than its matte counterpart.
Your Ultimate Farrow & Ball to Sherwin-Williams Match Guide
While an exact match is never guaranteed, extensive testing by designers and homeowners has revealed some very close contenders. This table provides a starting point for some of the most sought-after Farrow & Ball colors and their most popular Sherwin-Williams equivalents. Always test a sample before committing.
| Farrow & Ball Color | Closest Sherwin-Williams Match | Notes & Undertones |
|---|---|---|
| Hague Blue | SW 6244 Naval | Naval is a very close and popular match, slightly more saturated and a touch darker. |
| Elephant’s Breath | SW 7029 Agreeable Gray | A well-regarded match. Agreeable Gray can sometimes read slightly warmer. |
| Skimming Stone | SW 7671 On the Rocks | A good alternative, though On the Rocks has a slightly lower Light Reflectance Value (LRV), making it a touch darker. |
| Railings | SW 7076 Cyberspace | Cyberspace is an excellent match, capturing the soft, cool off-black essence of Railings. |
| Setting Plaster | SW 6058 Likeable Sand | Likeable Sand is a close option but may appear a bit pinker and less gray-toned in some lights. |
| Pigeon | SW 9132 Acacia Haze | Acacia Haze is a strong contender, sharing the same complex green-gray-blue undertones. |
| Down Pipe | SW 9560 Night Out | A very close match. Some also suggest SW 7075 Web Gray, which is slightly lighter. |
| Green Smoke | SW 6188 Shade-Grown | Shade-Grown captures the deep, moody green essence, though it can appear slightly darker. |
How to Get the Best Possible Match: A Step-by-Step Process
Relying solely on a pre-matched formula from a database is a gamble. To ensure you’re happy with the final result, you must take a hands-on approach and become an active participant in the matching process.
Step 1: Obtain a True Farrow & Ball Sample
Do not rely on a digital image from a website or Pinterest. Monitors are not color-calibrated. You must start with a physical, painted sample of the true Farrow & Ball color. The best option is to order a sample pot and paint a large swatch on a piece of white poster board.
Step 2: Take Your Sample to Sherwin-Williams for a Scan
Every Sherwin-Williams store is equipped with a spectrophotometer, a device that scans the color and generates a formula to replicate it. This is your technological starting point. Hand them your painted sample board for the most accurate reading.
Step 3: Insist on a Test Pot of the Match
This is the most critical step and is non-negotiable. Never, ever buy gallons of custom-matched paint without first testing a small sample pot. The few dollars you spend on a sample can save you hundreds in wasted paint and hours of frustration.
Step 4: Conduct Rigorous Home Testing
Take your Sherwin-Williams sample pot home and paint a large swatch (at least 2×2 feet) on a white poster board. Do not paint it directly on your wall, as the existing color will influence your perception. Move this sample board around the room and observe it at all times of the day: in the bright morning light, the warm afternoon sun, and under your artificial lighting at night. Compare it directly next to your original Farrow & Ball sample in every location.
Common Pitfalls and How to Avoid Them
Even with a careful process, mistakes can happen. Being aware of these common errors will help you navigate the nuances of color matching like a professional.
Ignoring the Sheen Difference: Farrow & Ball’s signature “Estate Emulsion” has a very chalky, 2% sheen level. Sherwin-Williams’ standard matte finishes are typically higher. This difference in reflectivity will inherently make the colors look different. Ask for the flattest finish available to get closer to the original’s appearance.
Forgetting About Primer: The color you are painting over can drastically change the final look of your new paint. For the truest color representation, especially when making a significant color change, use a high-quality, tinted primer recommended by the paint store staff.
Relying on a Name Alone: Don’t just ask the clerk to look up a Farrow & Ball match in their system. Formulas can be outdated or inaccurate. The only reliable method is to have your physical sample scanned and then test the resulting mix.
Beyond the Machine: The Underrated Value of a Skilled Paint Tech
The spectrophotometer is a fantastic tool, but it’s not infallible. It provides a starting formula, but the real magic often comes from the human eye of an experienced paint technician. They understand the nuances of their store’s tinting machines and pigments in a way a computer never can.
If your initial sample match seems slightly off—perhaps a little too green or a touch too warm—don’t be afraid to have a conversation. A skilled employee can often make tiny manual adjustments, adding a literal drop of a counteracting colorant to nudge the formula closer to your desired shade. Having a basic understanding of how to read paint formulas can empower you to have a more productive conversation about these subtle tweaks.
What If I Only Have a Digital Color Code?
Sometimes you might find a color you love online represented by a Hex or RGB code. While this is useful for digital design, it doesn’t translate directly into the world of physical paint pigments. However, it can serve as a useful starting point for color selection. Services and tools exist that can help you buy paint by hex code, essentially converting that digital information into the closest available paint color, which you should then, of course, sample and test rigorously.
Conclusion: Your Path to Attainable Luxury
Successfully matching a Farrow & Ball color in Sherwin-Williams paint is an art that balances technology with careful, real-world observation. While a chemically identical, 100% perfect match is unlikely due to differences in base paints and pigments, an aesthetically pleasing and visually indistinguishable result is absolutely achievable.
The key is to manage your expectations, follow a meticulous testing process, and treat the initial computer match as a starting point, not a final destination. By investing a small amount of time and effort into proper sampling, you can confidently achieve that high-end, nuanced color you love with the durable, accessible, and affordable paint you need.
