Craftsman vs Ariens Snowblower: The Unforgiving Truth Before You Buy
The first heavy snowfall blankets your neighborhood, and the familiar dread sets in. Shoveling means hours of back-breaking labor in the biting cold. You’ve decided this is the year you invest in a snowblower, but the central question paralyzes you: which brand can you trust to reclaim your winter?
You find yourself caught between two titans of the industry: Craftsman, the accessible household name, and Ariens, the brand professionals whisper about with reverence. This decision is more than just a purchase; it’s a long-term commitment to a machine that must perform when you need it most. This guide cuts through the marketing noise to reveal the critical differences that will determine your satisfaction for years to come.
You'll Learn About
The Core Conflict: A Tool vs. An Investment
Understanding the fundamental difference in philosophy between Craftsman and Ariens is the first step to making an informed choice. Craftsman, historically a Sears brand and now largely manufactured by MTD, targets the homeowner who needs a reliable tool at an accessible price point. Their machines are designed to meet the needs of a typical suburban driveway with moderate snowfall.
Ariens, on the other hand, positions itself as an investment in durability and power. Often called “The King of Snow,” Ariens builds machines with a focus on longevity and professional-grade performance, often using heavier-duty materials. This distinction forms the foundation of every comparison between the two brands.
Head-to-Head Breakdown: Where It Really Counts
When you’re facing a foot of wet, heavy snow, abstract philosophies don’t matter—only performance does. Let’s dissect the key components where these two brands diverge, revealing what you’re truly paying for.
Build Quality and Durability: The Steel Story
The most significant difference lies in the materials used. Ariens prides itself on all-steel construction, from the frame and handlebars to the auger housing and chute. This heavy-gauge steel provides rigidity and weight, which prevents the machine from “walking” or riding up on top of dense snow drifts. More importantly, it ensures the machine can withstand the inevitable bumps and jolts of winter work for decades.
Craftsman models, especially in the entry-level to mid-range, often incorporate more plastic and composite components to keep costs down. While modern polymers are strong, they can become brittle in extreme cold and are more susceptible to cracking from an impact with a hidden chunk of ice or a curb. While both brands use steel, the thickness and quality in an Ariens are typically superior, a fact echoed by long-time users and repair technicians.
Engine Performance and Reliability
A snowblower is nothing without a reliable engine that starts in sub-zero temperatures. Ariens primarily uses their own Ariens AX series engines, which are robust, winterized engines manufactured by LCT, a U.S.-based company. These engines have a stellar reputation for reliability and cold-weather performance.
Craftsman snowblowers feature engines from a variety of manufacturers, including Briggs & Stratton and their own branded engines made by companies like MTD. While these are generally reliable power plants, the consistency can vary from model to model. An issue where a snowblower runs for a few seconds then dies is often related to fuel system health, a critical maintenance point for any brand, but the core engineering of the Ariens AX series is specifically tailored for harsh winter conditions.
Snow Clearing Power and Features
Raw power comes from the combination of the engine, the auger, and the impeller. Ariens machines typically feature a high-speed, 14-inch impeller and large, serrated steel augers. This design aggressively pulls in snow and throws it further, a crucial feature for clearing wide driveways where you need to avoid blowing snow back onto cleared areas.
A standout feature on many Ariens models is the Auto-Turn steering technology. This differential-based system makes maneuvering the heavy machine nearly effortless, allowing for tight, zero-degree turns without fumbling with levers or triggers. Craftsman offers power steering on some of its higher-end models, but the intuitive and seamless operation of the Ariens Auto-Turn is often cited as a game-changer for usability.
Cost Comparison: Price Tag vs. True Value
There’s no denying the initial price difference. A Craftsman snowblower is almost always more affordable than a comparable Ariens model. This upfront savings is a major draw for budget-conscious homeowners. However, it’s essential to consider the total cost of ownership over the machine’s lifespan.
The superior build quality of an Ariens often translates to fewer repairs and a longer service life. When you compare it to other premium brands, as seen in the Ariens vs Cub Cadet snowblower debate, the focus remains on long-term resilience. A well-maintained Ariens can last 20-30 years, while a Craftsman may need replacement sooner, potentially negating the initial savings. The eventual snowblower scrap value of an Ariens is also often higher due to the demand for its durable parts.
Feature and Value Comparison Table
| Feature | Ariens | Craftsman |
|---|---|---|
| Price Range (2-Stage) | Premium ($1,200 – $2,500+) | Budget-Friendly to Mid-Range ($800 – $1,600) |
| Construction | All-steel housing, chute, and frame; cast-iron gear case | Steel housing with plastic components (chute, dashboard on some models) |
| Engine Type | Ariens AX Series (by LCT) | Varies by model (MTD, Briggs & Stratton, etc.) |
| Key Feature | Auto-Turn differential steering for effortless turns | Power steering on some models; widely available at big-box stores |
| Gear Case Warranty | Typically 5 years | Typically 1-2 years |
| Ideal User | Homeowners in heavy snow regions seeking a long-term investment | Homeowners with moderate snowfall and smaller areas on a budget |
Why You Might Still Choose Craftsman
Despite the clear advantages of Ariens in build quality, choosing Craftsman can be a perfectly logical decision. For many people, an all-steel, professional-grade machine is simply overkill. If you have a small to medium-sized paved driveway and live in an area that gets moderate, fluffy snow, a Craftsman can serve you well for many years.
Their widespread availability at retailers like Lowe’s means they are easy to purchase and service. For a homeowner who can’t justify spending over a thousand dollars on a machine they’ll use a handful of times a year, the value proposition of a Craftsman is hard to beat.
When is Ariens the Only Real Choice?
The argument for Ariens becomes undeniable under specific conditions. If you live in a region known for heavy, wet “heart attack” snow, the power and all-steel construction of an Ariens are not luxuries—they are necessities. The extra weight and aggressive auger design prevent the machine from bogging down or riding up over compacted snow.
Furthermore, if you have a long, gravel driveway or a large area to clear, the durability and superior throwing distance of an Ariens will save you significant time and frustration. It’s built for those who view snow removal as a serious task, not an occasional chore. For these users, buying a less capable machine often leads to regret and the need for an upgrade after just a few seasons.
The Final Verdict: Matching the Machine to Your Mission
The choice between Craftsman and Ariens is a choice between fulfilling a need and making an investment. Neither brand is universally “better”; they simply serve different masters.
You should buy a Craftsman if:
- You are on a strict budget and prioritize upfront cost.
- You have a small or medium-sized paved driveway.
- You experience light to moderate snowfall annually.
You should buy an Ariens if:
- You live in a region with heavy, frequent, or wet snowfall.
- You have a large area or a gravel driveway to clear.
- You value long-term durability and view the purchase as a 20+ year investment.
Ultimately, the best snowblower is the one that reliably starts in the freezing cold and confidently clears your path. By honestly assessing your budget, your property’s demands, and the type of winter you face, you can choose the machine that will serve you faithfully, storm after storm.
Frequently Asked Questions
Which brand is more reliable, Craftsman or Ariens?
Ariens is generally considered to be the more reliable and durable brand, built to last with thicker steel components. While both brands can produce reliable snowblowers, Ariens is often viewed as a premium brand with a reputation for longevity.
What is the main difference between Craftsman and Ariens snowblowers?
The primary difference lies in the engine and build quality. Ariens snowblowers typically feature their own AX series engines and are constructed with more steel components, while Craftsman models often use MTD engines and may incorporate more plastic parts. This difference in construction often contributes to Ariens being heavier and more robust.
Are Ariens snowblowers more expensive than Craftsman?
Yes, Ariens snowblowers generally have a higher price point than Craftsman models. However, many users feel that the higher cost of an Ariens is justified by its superior build quality, durability, and performance, offering better long-term value.
Which brand is easier to use?
Ariens snowblowers are often highlighted for their ease of use, featuring user-friendly setups and keyless starts on some models. While Craftsman models are often lighter, which can make them easier to maneuver, Ariens machines are noted for features that enhance usability.
Which brand is better for heavy, wet snow?
With more powerful engines and robust steel construction, Ariens snowblowers are generally better equipped to handle heavy, wet snow. Their design allows them to throw snow farther and more effectively, which is a significant advantage in challenging snow conditions.
Final Words
The choice between Craftsman and Ariens comes down to your unique needs, budget, and long-term goals. If you’re looking for a solid, budget-friendly option that’s perfect for lighter, occasional use, Craftsman may be your best bet.
It offers reliable performance and easy accessibility, ideal for homeowners who want a hassle-free experience. On the other hand, if you want a machine that’s built to withstand harsh winters and heavy-duty snow clearing, Ariens is the professional-grade choice that promises durability, exceptional power, and top-notch engineering.
Whichever brand you choose, remember: a snowblower isn’t just an investment in convenience, it’s an investment in peace of mind during winter’s worst. Take the time to weigh your options, and know that your decision will pay off every time the snow falls and you’re ready to clear your driveway with ease.
