Cliq Cabinets vs KraftMaid: The Truth Before You Spend a Dime
Choosing kitchen cabinets can feel like navigating a minefield of options, each promising durability, style, and value. The central problem for many homeowners is deciphering the real-world differences between a popular online brand like CliqStudios and an established showroom giant like KraftMaid. One choice could lead to a budget-friendly, stylish kitchen, while the other might result in frustrating delays, mismatched finishes, or a final product that doesn’t live up to its price tag.
The core of the issue lies in the business models. CliqStudios operates primarily online, offering semi-custom cabinets directly to consumers, which often translates to lower prices. KraftMaid, a veteran of the industry, is a semi-custom brand available through big-box stores and local dealers, promising a more traditional, hands-on purchasing experience but often at a higher cost. Understanding which path is right for your project requires a deep dive into construction quality, design flexibility, customer support, and long-term performance.
You'll Learn About
Construction and Materials: A Tale of Two Philosophies
The foundation of any good cabinet is its construction, and this is where the first major distinctions between CliqStudios and KraftMaid appear. Both brands offer different tiers of quality, but their standard offerings reveal their core philosophies. Making the wrong choice here can impact the longevity and durability of your entire kitchen.
CliqStudios provides several cabinet lines, with their higher-end options, like the Signature and Signature Plus lines, featuring plywood box construction. Plywood is known for its superior moisture resistance and screw-holding power, making it a desirable material for kitchen environments. Their drawer boxes are typically made from 5/8-inch thick solid hardwood with dovetail joints, a hallmark of quality construction that ensures strength and longevity.
KraftMaid’s standard cabinet boxes are often made from furniture board (particle board), with an upgrade option to all-plywood construction. While high-quality furniture board can be stable, plywood is generally considered the more durable choice, especially in areas prone to moisture. KraftMaid also uses solid hardwood for its doors and drawer fronts and employs durable dovetail joinery for its drawers, ensuring they can handle the rigors of daily use.
The Finish Factor: Durability and Appearance
A cabinet’s finish is not just about color; it’s a crucial layer of protection against stains, moisture, and daily wear. A poor finish can lead to premature chipping, peeling, and discoloration, drastically shortening the lifespan and aesthetic appeal of your kitchen. Both brands apply multi-step finishing processes, but customer experiences highlight some key differences.
KraftMaid utilizes its DuraKraft Plus finishing system, a catalyzed conversion varnish designed to resist wear, fading, and common household chemicals. This robust finish is often praised for its durability and consistent appearance. However, some homeowners have reported issues with paint peeling or inconsistent color, particularly with lighter finishes. These issues underscore the importance of careful inspection upon delivery.
CliqStudios also employs a multi-step finishing process designed for durability. Reviews often commend the smooth, consistent finish of their cabinets. However, like any painted cabinet, they are not immune to chipping or wear, especially in high-traffic areas. The key takeaway is that while both brands offer durable finishes, proper care and immediate attention to any shipping damage are crucial for long-term satisfaction.
The Design and Ordering Experience: Online Convenience vs. In-Person Guidance
How you design and order your cabinets significantly impacts the final outcome. This is perhaps the most significant difference between CliqStudios and KraftMaid. The choice between a digital-first process and a traditional showroom experience depends entirely on your comfort level with design, your desire for professional hand-holding, and your project’s complexity.
CliqStudios offers a free online design service, connecting you with an in-house designer who helps create your kitchen layout using your measurements and photos. This process is convenient, allowing you to manage your project from home with multiple revisions and 3D renderings. This model is ideal for those who are comfortable with online collaboration and want to take a more active role in the design process.
In contrast, KraftMaid is sold through retailers like Lowe’s and Home Depot, as well as independent kitchen dealers. This allows you to work with a designer in a showroom, see physical samples, and get a more tangible feel for the products. This can be invaluable for homeowners who are less confident in their design skills or who simply prefer face-to-face interaction. However, the quality of the design support can vary significantly depending on the experience of the individual designer at the specific retail location.
Customization and Flexibility: Finding the Perfect Fit
No two kitchens are exactly alike, and the ability to customize cabinets to fit your unique space is a major consideration. Both CliqStudios and KraftMaid are semi-custom brands, meaning they offer more flexibility than stock cabinets but less than fully custom options. Understanding the extent of their customization options is key to achieving a high-end, built-in look.
KraftMaid generally offers a wider array of door styles, finishes, and wood species. They also provide more extensive modification options, allowing for changes in cabinet depth, height, and width. This greater flexibility can be a significant advantage in older homes with unusual dimensions or for homeowners with very specific design requirements. A deeper dive into their catalog reveals options like custom paint colors and unique storage solutions that can elevate a kitchen’s functionality.
CliqStudios also offers a respectable range of styles and finishes, focusing on popular choices like Shaker and slab doors. While their modification options may be more limited than KraftMaid’s, they still provide enough flexibility for most standard kitchen layouts. For many homeowners, the curated selection offered by CliqStudios is less overwhelming and provides a more straightforward path to a beautiful kitchen.
Cost and Value: A Clear Divide
For most people, the budget is a driving force behind their cabinet choice. This is where the online, direct-to-consumer model of CliqStudios creates a clear advantage over the traditional retail model of KraftMaid. However, the lowest price doesn’t always equate to the best value, and it’s essential to consider what you’re getting for your money.
CliqStudios is generally more affordable than KraftMaid for a comparable kitchen layout. By selling directly online, they eliminate the overhead associated with showrooms and dealer markups. This can result in significant savings, often making them a strong contender for budget-conscious homeowners who still want quality features like plywood construction and soft-close hardware.
KraftMaid’s pricing reflects its retail distribution model and its broader range of customization options. While promotions and sales at big-box stores can make them more competitive, they typically represent a larger investment. The value proposition for KraftMaid lies in its extensive selection, established reputation, and the peace of mind that comes with a lifetime limited warranty and in-person customer support.
| Feature | CliqStudios | KraftMaid |
|---|---|---|
| Business Model | Online, direct-to-consumer | Sold through big-box stores and dealers |
| Standard Box Construction | Plywood options available | Furniture board (plywood upgrade available) |
| Drawer Construction | Solid wood, dovetail joints | Solid wood, dovetail joints |
| Design Process | Free online design service | In-person design at retail locations |
| Customization | Good selection of popular styles; some modifications | Extensive styles, finishes, and modifications |
| Price Point | More affordable | Mid-to-upper range |
| Lead Time | Varies; can have delays | Generally longer lead times |
| Warranty | Limited Lifetime Warranty | Limited Lifetime Warranty |
Customer Service and Post-Purchase Support: The Make-or-Break Factor
Even the best-laid plans can go awry, and the quality of a company’s customer service can make all the difference between a minor hiccup and a full-blown renovation nightmare. From damaged items to warranty claims, how a company responds to problems is a critical part of the overall experience.
CliqStudios’ customer support is handled remotely via phone and email. While many customers report positive experiences with their design team, some have faced challenges with post-sale support, citing long wait times for replacement parts and difficulties in communication. It is important to note that the company underwent a change in ownership in 2020, and reports suggest that service has been improving since.
With KraftMaid, your point of contact for any issues is typically the retailer where you made the purchase. This can be both a blessing and a curse. An experienced and proactive designer at a local dealer can be a powerful advocate, helping to resolve issues quickly. Conversely, dealing with a large, impersonal big-box store can sometimes lead to frustration and delays as you navigate their corporate structure. KraftMaid itself offers a limited lifetime warranty, but the process of filing a claim often starts with the retailer.
Making the Final Decision: Which is Right for You?
Ultimately, the choice between CliqStudios and KraftMaid comes down to your priorities, budget, and comfort level with the renovation process. There is no single “best” answer, only the best choice for your specific project.
Choose CliqStudios if:
- You are budget-conscious and looking for the best value for your money.
- You are comfortable with an online design and ordering process.
- You want quality features like plywood construction as a standard option.
- Your kitchen layout is relatively straightforward without needing extensive custom modifications.
Choose KraftMaid if:
- You prefer an in-person design experience where you can see and touch the products.
- You require extensive customization options to fit a unique space or achieve a specific look.
- A long-standing brand reputation and the backing of a major retailer are important to you.
- Your budget is more flexible, and you prioritize a vast selection of styles and finishes.
Regardless of your choice, remember that the success of your kitchen remodel also heavily depends on a skilled installer. For a broader perspective on cabinet options, you might find our comparison of Medallion Cabinets vs KraftMaid insightful. Similarly, choosing the right appliances is just as crucial, and our analysis of Thermador vs Miele refrigerators can help you make an informed decision. Finally, don’t overlook the impact of cabinet size on your kitchen’s functionality; our guide on 30 vs 36 inch cabinets explores this topic in detail.
