Boothbay Blue vs Evening Blue: Don’t Pick Before Reading This!
Choosing an exterior color for your home is a monumental decision. It dictates curb appeal, reflects your personal style, and is a significant financial investment you’ll live with for years. The choice becomes even harder when you’re faced with two stunning, yet deceptively similar, shades like Boothbay Blue and Evening Blue from James Hardie.
Many homeowners find themselves paralyzed, staring at tiny samples, unable to visualize how these colors will truly look on their home. This guide is designed to eliminate that uncertainty, providing a deep, comprehensive comparison to help you make a confident and informed choice.
You'll Learn About
The Siding Color Dilemma: Why Is This So Hard?
Picking a siding color feels permanent because it largely is. Unlike interior paint, you can’t easily or inexpensively change your home’s exterior. This pressure is compounded by factors that many homeowners don’t fully consider until it’s too late.
The most critical and often misunderstood factor is the role of natural light and undertones. A color that looks like a perfect medium blue on a sample card can appear gray, green, or even nearly black depending on the time of day, the season, and the direction your house faces.
Understanding Undertones: The Secret to Color Success
Undertones are the subtle hints of color that hide within a primary shade. They are the reason two “blue” sidings can look dramatically different once installed. Failing to account for these hidden hues is the number one reason for siding color regret.
For blue sidings, the most common undertones are gray and green. These undertones react powerfully with natural light and the surrounding environment, such as lush green trees or the wide-open sky, completely changing the perceived color of your home.
Deep Dive: Unpacking James Hardie’s Boothbay Blue
Boothbay Blue is a sophisticated, muted blue that offers a softer, more serene aesthetic. It’s often described as a calming, mid-tone shade that feels both classic and contemporary, making it a highly versatile choice for various architectural styles.
Think of the color of the water on a calm, slightly overcast day. This shade is designed to feel tranquil and inviting, evoking a sense of peaceful, waterside living.
The Chameleon-Like Undertones of Boothbay Blue
The defining characteristic of Boothbay Blue is its strong gray and green undertones. This is what gives the color its complexity and also its “chameleon” quality. In direct, bright sunlight, the blue is more prominent, but the green can also come forward, especially if your home is surrounded by landscaping or trees.
On cloudy days or on walls that are frequently in shadow (like a north-facing wall), the gray undertones take over, making the siding appear as a distinguished blue-gray. This constant shift is either a feature you’ll love for its dynamic nature or dislike for its unpredictability.
Best Pairings and Architectural Styles for Boothbay Blue
Boothbay Blue shines on styles like Coastal, Craftsman, and modern Farmhouse. Its softer nature pairs exceptionally well with crisp, clean trim colors like James Hardie’s Arctic White, which creates a timeless, classic contrast. For a warmer, more subtle look, it can also be paired with off-whites or even a light beige trim.
Because of its earthy green undertones, it also harmonizes beautifully with natural materials like stone, brick accents, and wood features on porches or gables.
Deep Dive: Unpacking James Hardie’s Evening Blue
Evening Blue is a bolder, deeper, and more classic navy-style blue. It makes a strong, confident statement and exudes an air of timeless elegance and sophistication. It is a darker, more saturated color that is less likely to be misinterpreted.
This is the color of a classic navy blazer or the sky just after sunset. It’s assertive and formal, providing a dramatic and impactful look that can significantly elevate a home’s presence.
The Steadfast Undertones of Evening Blue
Compared to Boothbay Blue, Evening Blue has much more subtle undertones. It is primarily a deep blue with only a slight gray undertone to give it sophistication and prevent it from looking overly bright. This lack of strong green undertones makes it far more consistent in its appearance.
What you see on the sample is largely what you get on the house, regardless of the lighting conditions. While it will naturally look darker in the shade, it will consistently read as a deep blue, not gray or green.
Best Pairings and Architectural Styles for Evening Blue
Evening Blue is a perfect match for more traditional architectural styles like Colonial, Georgian, and Transitional homes. Its formal appearance is powerfully enhanced when paired with a bright Arctic White trim, creating a striking, high-contrast look that is always in style.
It also pairs well with darker accents, such as Iron Gray, on gables or shutters to create a layered, moody vibe. This color provides a fantastic backdrop for showcasing architectural details and creating a sense of drama and formality.
Boothbay Blue vs. Evening Blue: A Head-to-Head Comparison
The best way to understand the differences is to see them side-by-side. While both are in the blue family, their personality, undertones, and the way they interact with light set them worlds apart. Choosing the right one depends entirely on the aesthetic you want to achieve.
Making a decision requires looking beyond the base color and considering these nuanced characteristics. The following table breaks down the key attributes of each color to simplify your choice.
| Feature | Boothbay Blue | Evening Blue |
|---|---|---|
| Overall Hue | Soft, Muted Gray-Blue | Deep, Classic Navy Blue |
| Primary Undertones | Strong Green and Gray | Subtle Gray |
| Color Consistency | Variable; changes with light | Consistent; reads as blue in all light |
| Light Reflectance Value (LRV) | Higher (appears lighter) | Lower (appears darker) |
| Overall Vibe | Calm, Serene, Earthy, Coastal | Bold, Formal, Timeless, Elegant |
| Best Architectural Styles | Craftsman, Coastal, Farmhouse | Colonial, Traditional, Transitional |
| Pairs Best With | Arctic White, Off-Whites, Stone | Arctic White, Iron Gray, Wood Tones |
The Ultimate Deciding Factor: Your Home’s Unique Lighting
No amount of research can replace seeing the colors in your own space. The direction your home faces will dramatically alter these colors. A north-facing home receives cool, indirect light, which will amplify the gray in Boothbay Blue and make Evening Blue appear even darker.
Conversely, a south-facing home gets intense, warm light all day, which will bring out the blue and green in Boothbay Blue and keep Evening Blue looking like a true, rich navy. You must observe samples on all sides of your house at all times of day.
Making the Final Decision: A Practical Guide
You’ve done the research, now it’s time for action. Follow these non-negotiable steps to ensure you make a choice you will love for decades.
Step 1: Get Large Samples. Period.
Do not make a decision based on a tiny one-inch chip or a picture online. Go to a supplier and get the largest samples of James Hardie siding you can find in both colors. You need to see how the texture and finish interact with light.
Step 2: Test Samples Correctly
Do not just hold the samples up against your current siding. Place them on every side of your house—north, south, east, and west. Observe them in the morning, at noon, in the late afternoon, and on both sunny and cloudy days.
Step 3: Consider Your Fixed Elements
Your siding color must coordinate with the elements that are not changing. Look at your roof color (is it black, brown, gray?), any stone or brick accents, and your window frame colors. A cool blue can clash with a warm brown roof.
Step 4: Look at Your Landscape and Neighbors
The green from your lawn and trees will reflect onto your siding, amplifying the green undertones in Boothbay Blue. Also, consider your neighborhood context. While you should choose what you love, you may not want your home to clash dramatically with your immediate neighbors.
Beyond the Blue: Coordinating Trim and Accents
Once you’ve chosen your main color, the trim and accents are what will truly complete the look. For both Boothbay Blue and Evening Blue, Arctic White is the most popular and failsafe trim choice, delivering a crisp, clean finish that makes the blue pop.
However, you can create a more custom palette. If you need a specific shade for your front door or shutters, finding a perfect James Hardie paint match with Sherwin Williams can provide endless possibilities for customization and ensure every element of your exterior is cohesive.
Common Mistakes to Avoid
Many homeowners fall into the same traps when selecting exterior colors. Being aware of these common pitfalls can save you from a costly mistake and immense regret.
- Ignoring Undertones: Believing that “blue is just blue” is the fastest path to disappointment. Acknowledge how the hidden green or gray will present itself in your specific environment.
- Choosing from a Small Chip: A small color sample cannot physically gather enough light to show you how it will truly look across an entire wall. Always use large samples.
- Forgetting the Roof: The roof is one of the largest surfaces on your home. A warm-toned roof with a cool-toned siding can create a jarring, unharmonious look.
Finalizing your home’s exterior palette is just as crucial as selecting the right paint colors for Sterling Oak floors inside; it establishes the foundational aesthetic of your entire property. After perfecting your home’s exterior, you can focus on interior upgrades that improve daily life, ensuring every detail of your home is just right.
Conclusion: The Right Blue for You
The choice between Boothbay Blue and Evening Blue comes down to the personality you want for your home. Both are beautiful, durable, and high-quality options from James Hardie that will protect and beautify your home for years.
Choose Boothbay Blue if you want a softer, more serene home with a dynamic color that shifts with the light, perfectly suited for a coastal or farmhouse design. Choose Evening Blue if you desire a bold, classic, and elegant home with a consistent, deep color that makes a timeless and sophisticated statement. By following the practical steps of testing large samples in your own unique environment, you now have the expertise to make the perfect choice with confidence.
